1824-25 * John H. Cotton
1826-29 * Silas A. Bowen
1830 * Daniel L. Potter
1831 * John Purdy
1851-52 * Samuel L. Butler
1853-58 * Daniel L. Potter
1859 * Brazillai Davenport
1860 * John S. Webster
1861-62 * Gamaliel Washburn
1863 * Horatio Needham
1864 * Samuel L. Butler
1865-66 * George M. Hall
1867-71 * Russell Taft
1872-74 * Joseph L. Perkins
1875-77 * Albert B. Jewett
1878-80 * Edward S. Dana
1881-82 * George S. Tyler
1883-84 * Alfred A. Hall
1885 * Thad A. Chapman
1886 * George W. Wing
1887-88 * Delos M. Bacon
1889-90 * Will F. Lewis
1891-92 * Kitteridge Haskins
1893-94 * Marsh O. Perkins
1895 * Silas A. Cummings
1896-97 * Robert J. Wright
1898-99 * Jesse E. Thompson
1900 * Daniel E. Nicholson
1901 * Dan Payson
1902 * Dan P. Webster
1903 * Silas N. Danforth
1904 * William W. Kinsley
1905 * Charles Calderwood
1906 * Elihu B. Taft
1907 * J. Henry Jackson
1908 * George H. Jackson
1909 * Frank W. Dewey
1910 * Daniel S. Danforth
1911 * George F. Root
1912 * Frank L. Clark
1913 * William W. Brewster
1914 * Olin W. Dailey
1915 * Edward L. Blake
1916 * Frank B. Outman
1917 * Frederick Babbitt
1918 * William L. Herrick
1919 * Major C. Houghton
1920 * Otis C. Kelton
1921 * George B. Wheeler
1922 * Arthur Farnsworth

1923 * Frederick Briggs
1924 * Henry L. Ballou
1925 * Aaron H. Grout
1926 * Frank L. Small
1927 * William W. Nichols
1928 * Zeno S. Waterman
1929 * Thomas H. Chaney
1930 * John R. Temple
1931 * Martin L. Averill
1932 * George M. Clay
1933 * George P. Lovell
1934 * Allen M. Hall
1935 * John O. Baxendale
1936 * G. Forest Dow
1937 * G. Wilbur Mower
1938 * Alvi Calderwood
1939 * Ernest W. Savage
1940 * Earl S. Wright
1941 * J. Harold Stacey
1942 * G. Milan Smith
1943 * P. Conant Voter
1944 * Harley M. Watkins
1945 * Willard K. Saunders
1946 * Harold L. Cady
1947 * Waldron C. Biggs
1948 * Orville N. Kew
1949 * Sterry Waterman
1950 * Alfred A. Bishop
1951 * Frederick Fletcher
1952 * Walker F. Niles
1953 * Raymond L. Brown
1954 * J. W. Murdock, Sr.
1955 * Paul L. Glynn
1956 * Edward W. Curtis
1957 * Arthur E. Dietrich
1958 * Francis Woodcock
1959 * George E. Cummings
1960 * Arthur D. Bishop
1961 * Ralph E. Berry
1962 * Rudolph D. Smith
1963 * H. Herman Hertzberg
1964 * Parker B. Blake
1965 * Edward S. Pike
1966 * Franklyn Churchil
1967 * Frank W. Bailey
1968 * Welland S. Horn
1969 * Brooks W. Booth
1970 * Peter L. Butynski
1971 * Harold S. Burroughs
1972 * Raymond F. Sutton